Zum Inhalt

Lab 7: Managing and installing software

Objectives

After completing this lab, you will be able to:

  • Query packages for information
  • Install software from binary packages
  • Resolve some basic dependency issues
  • Compile and install software from the source

Estimated time to complete this lab: 90 minutes

Binary files and source files

The applications installed on your system depend on a few factors. The major factor depends on the software package groups selected during the operating system installation. The other factor depends on what has been done to the system since its use.

You will find that one of your routine tasks as a Systems Administrator is software management. This often involves:

  • installing new software
  • uninstalling software
  • updating already installed software

Installing software on Linux based systems uses several methods. You can install from source or precompiled binaries. The latter method is the easiest way, but it is also the least customizable. When you install from precompiled binaries, most of the work is already done for you. Still, you do need to know the name and where to find the particular software you want.

Almost all software originally come as C or "C++" programming language source files. The source programs are usually distributed as archives of source files. Usually tar’ed or gzip’ed d or bzip2’ed files. This means they come compressed or as a single bundle.

Most developers have made their source code conform to GNU standards, making sharing easier. It also means that the packages will compile on any UNIX or UNIX-like system (e.g., Linux).

RPM is the underlying tool for managing applications (packages) on Red Hat based distributions such as Rocky Linux, Fedora, Red Hat Enterprise Linux (RHEL), openSuSE, Mandrake, and so on.

The applications used for managing software on Linux distributions are called package managers. Examples are:

  • The Red Hat Package Manager (rpm). The packages have the suffix “ .rpm”
  • The Debian package management system (dpkg). The packages have the suffix “ .deb”

Some popular command-line options and syntax for the RPM command are listed next:

rpm

Usage: rpm [OPTION...]

QUERYING PACKAGES

Query options (with -q or --query):
  -c, --configfiles                  list all configuration files
  -d, --docfiles                     list all documentation files
  -L, --licensefiles                 list all license files
  -A, --artifactfiles                list all artifact files
      --dump                         dump basic file information
  -l, --list                         list files in package
      --queryformat=QUERYFORMAT      use the following query format
  -s, --state                        display the states of the listed files

VERIFYING PACKAGES

Verify options (with -V or --verify):
      --nofiledigest                 don't verify digest of files
      --nofiles                      don't verify files in package
      --nodeps                       don't verify package dependencies
      --noscript                     don't execute verify script(s)

INSTALLING, UPGRADING, AND REMOVING PACKAGES

Install/Upgrade/Erase options:
      --allfiles                     install all files, even configurations that might otherwise be skipped
  -e, --erase=<package>+             erase (uninstall) package
      --excludedocs                  do not install documentation
      --excludepath=<path>           skip files with leading component <path>
      --force                        shorthand for --replacepkgs --replacefiles
  -F, --freshen=<packagefile>+       upgrade package(s) if already installed
  -h, --hash                         print hash marks as package installs (good with -v)
      --noverify                     shorthand for --ignorepayload --ignoresignature
  -i, --install                      install package(s)
      --nodeps                       do not verify package dependencies
      --noscripts                    do not execute package scriptlet(s)
      --percent                      print percentages as package installs
      --prefix=<dir>                 relocate the package to <dir>, if relocatable
      --relocate=<old>=<new>         relocate files from path <old> to <new>
      --replacefiles                 ignore file conflicts between packages
      --replacepkgs                  reinstall if the package is already present
      --test                         don't install, but tell if it would work or not
  -U, --upgrade=<packagefile>+       upgrade package(s)
      --reinstall=<packagefile>+     reinstall package(s)

Exercise 1

Installing, querying and uninstalling packages

In this Lab, you will learn how to use the RPM system and install a sample application.

Tip

You have lots of options for where to obtain Rocky Linux packages from. You can manually download them from trusted [or untrusted] repositories. You can get them from the distribution ISO. You can get them from a centrally shared location using protocols such as - nfs, git, https, ftp, smb, cifs and so on. If you are curious you can view the following official website and browse through the applicable repository for the desired package(s):

https://download.rockylinux.org/pub/rocky/8.8/

To query packages for information

  1. To see a list of all the packages currently installed on your local system type:

    $ rpm -qa
    python3-gobject-base-*
    NetworkManager-*
    rocky-repos-*
    ...<OUTPUT TRUNCATED>...
    

    You should see a long list.

  2. Let us delve a little deeper and learn more about one of the packages installed on the system. We will examine NetworkManager. We will use the --query (-q) and --info (-i) options with the rpm command. Type:

    $ rpm -qi NetworkManager
    Name        : NetworkManager
    Epoch       : 1
    ...<OUTPUT TRUNCATED>...
    

    That is a great deal of information (metadata)!

  3. Let us say we are only interested in the Summary field of the previous command. We can use rpm's --queryformat option to filter the information that we get back from the query option.

    For example, to view only the Summary field, type:

    rpm -q --queryformat '%{summary}\n' NetworkManager
    

    The name of the field is case-insensitive.

  4. To view both the Version and Summary fields of the installed NetworkManager package type:

    rpm -q --queryformat '%{version}  %{summary}\n' NetworkManager
    
  5. Type the command to view information about the bash package that is installed on the system.

    rpm -qi bash
    

    Note

    The previous exercises were querying and working with packages already installed on the system. In the following exercises, we'll start working with packages that have not yet installed. We'll use the DNF application to download the packages we'll use in the following steps.

  6. First, ensure the wget application is not already installed on the system. Type:

    rpm -q wget
    package wget is not installed
    

    It looks like wget is not installed on our demo system.

  7. As of Rocky Linux 8.x, the dnf download command will allow you to get the latest rpm package for wget. Type:

    dnf download wget
    
  8. Use the ls command to ensure that the package was downloaded into your current directory. Type:

    ls -lh wg*
    
  9. Use the rpm command to query for information about the downloaded wget-*.rpm. Type:

    rpm -qip wget-*.rpm
    Name        : wget
    Architecture: x86_64
    Install Date: (not installed)
    Group       : Applications/Internet
    ...<TRUNCATED>...
    

    Question

    From your output in the previous step, what exactly is the wget package? Hint: you can use the rpm query format option to view the description field for the download package.

  10. If you are interested in the wget files-.rpm package, you could list all the files included in the package by typing:

    rpm -qlp wget-*.rpm | head
    /etc/wgetrc
    /usr/bin/wget
    ...<TRUNCATED>...
    /usr/share/doc/wget/AUTHORS
    /usr/share/doc/wget/COPYING
    /usr/share/doc/wget/MAILING-LIST
    /usr/share/doc/wget/NEWS
    
  11. Let us view the contents of the /usr/share/doc/wget/AUTHORS file listed as part of the wget package. We will use the cat command. Type:

    cat /usr/share/doc/wget/AUTHORS
    cat: /usr/share/doc/wget/AUTHORS: No such file or directory
    

    wget has not [yet] been installed on our demo system! And so, we can't view the AUTHORS file that is packaged with it!

  12. View the list of files that come with another package (curl) that is already installed on the system. Type:

    $ rpm -ql curl
    /usr/bin/curl
    /usr/lib/.build-id
    /usr/lib/.build-id/fc
    ...<>...
    

    Note

    You will notice that you did not have to refer to the full name of the curl package in the previous command. This is because curl is already installed.

Extended knowledge about package name

  • Full package name : When you download a package from a trusted source (for example - vendor website, developer repository), the name of the downloaded file is the full package name, such as -- htop-3.2.1-1.el8.x86_64.rpm. When using the rpm command to install/update this package, the object operated by the command must be the full name (or matching wildcard equivalent) of the package, such as:

    rpm -ivh htop-3.2.1-1.el8.x86_64.rpm
    
    rpm -Uvh htop-3.2.1-1.*.rpm
    
    rpm -qip htop-3.*.rpm
    
    rpm -qlp wget-1.19.5-11.el8.x86_64.rpm
    

    The full name of the package follows a naming convention similar to this —— [Package_Name]-[Version]-[Release].[OS].[Arch].rpm or [Package_Name]-[Version]-[Release].[OS].[Arch].src.rpm

  • Package name: Because RPM uses a database to manage software, the database will have corresponding records once the package installation completes. Currently, the operating object of the rpm command only needs to type the package name. such as:

    rpm -qi bash
    
    rpm -q systemd
    
    rpm -ql chrony
    

Exercise 2

Package integrity

  1. It is possible to download or end up with a corrupted or tainted file. Verify the integrity of the wget package that you downloaded. Type:

    rpm -K  wget-*.rpm
    wget-1.19.5-10.el8.x86_64.rpm: digests signatures OK
    

    The "digests signatures OK" message in the output shows the package is fine.

  2. Let us be malicious and deliberately alter the downloaded package. This can be done by adding anything to, or removing something from, the original package. Anything that changes the package in a way the original packagers did not intend will corrupt the package. We will alter the file using the echo command to add the string "haha" to the package. Type:

    echo haha >> wget-1.19.5-10.el8.x86_64.rpm 
    
  3. Now try to verify the integrity of the package again using rpm's -K option.

    $ rpm -K  wget-*.rpm
    wget-1.19.5-10.el8.x86_64.rpm: DIGESTS SIGNATURES NOT OK
    

    It is a very different message now. The output "DIGESTS SIGNATURES NOT OK" clearly warns you should not try using or installing the package. It should no longer be trusted.

  4. Use the rm command to delete the corrupted wget package file and download a fresh copy using dnf. Type:

    rm wget-*.rpm  && dnf download wget
    

    Check one more time that the newly downloaded package passes RPMs integrity checks.

Exercise 3

Installing packages

While installing software on your system, you might stumble on “failed dependencies” issues. This is especially common when using the low-level RPM utility to manage applications on a system manually.

For example, if you try to install package “abc.rpm” the RPM installer might complain about some failed dependencies. It might tell you that package “abc.rpm” requires another package, “xyz.rpm” to first be installed. The dependencies issue arises because software applications almost always depend on another software or library. If a required program or shared library is not already on the system, that prerequisite must be satisfied before installing the target application.

The low-level RPM utility often knows about the inter-dependencies between applications. But it does not usually know how or where to obtain the application or library needed to resolve the issue. Stated another way, RPM knows the what and how but does not have the built-in ability to answer the where question. This is where tools like dnf, yum, and so on shine.

To install packages

In this exercise you will try to install the wget package (wget-*.rpm).

  1. Try installing the wget application. Use RPM's -ivh command line options. Type:

    rpm -ivh wget-*.rpm
    error: Failed dependencies:
        libmetalink.so.3()(64bit) is needed by wget-*
    

    Right away - a dependency problem! The sample output shows that wget needs some kind of library file named "libmetalink.so.3"

    Note

    According to the output of the test above, the wget-.rpm package requires that the libmetalink-.rpm package be installed. In other words, libmetalink is a prerequisite for installing wget-.rpm. You can forcefully install wget-.rpm package using the “nodeps” option if you absolutely know what you are doing, but this is generally a BAD practice.

  2. RPM has helpfully given us a hint for what is missing. You will remember that rpm knows the what and how but does not necessarily know the where. Let us use the dnf utility to determine the package name that provides the missing library. Type:

    $ dnf whatprovides libmetalink.so.3
    ...<TRUNCATED>...
    libmetalink-* : Metalink library written in C
    Repo        : baseos
    Matched from:
    Provide    : libmetalink.so.3
    
  3. From the output, we need to download the libmetalink package that provides the missing library. Specifically, we want the 64bit version of the library. Let us call on a separate utility (dnf) to help us find and download the package for our demo 64-bit (x86_64) architecture. Type:

    dnf download --arch x86_64  libmetalink
    
  4. You should now have at least 2 rpm packages in your working directory. Use the ls command to confirm this.

  5. Install the missing libmetalink dependency. Type:

    sudo rpm -ivh libmetalink-*.rpm
    
  6. With the dependency now installed, we can now revisit our original objective of installing the wget package. Type:

    sudo rpm -ivh wget-*.rpm
    

    Note

    RPM supports transactions. In the previous exercises, we could have performed a single rpm transaction that included the original package we wanted to install and all the packages and libraries it depended on. A single command such as the one below would have sufficed:

    ```bash
    rpm -Uvh  wget-*.rpm  libmetalink-*.rpm
    ```
    
  7. Moment of truth now. Try running the wget program without any option to see if it is installed. Type:

    wget
    
  8. Let us see wget in action. Use wget to download a file from the internet from the command line. Type:

    wget  https://kernel.org
    

    This will download the default index.html from kernel.org website!

  9. Use rpm to view a list of all the files included with the wget application.

  10. Use rpm to view any documentation packaged with wget.

  11. Use rpm to view the list of all the binaries installed with the wget package.

  12. You had to install the libmetalink package to install wget. Try running or executing libmetalink from the command-line. Type:

    libmetalink
    -bash: libmetalink: command not found
    

    Attention

    What gives? Why can't you run or execute libmetalink?

To import a public key via rpm

Tip

The GPG keys used for signing packages used in the Rocky Linux project can be obtained from various sources such as - the Project website, ftp site, distribution media, local source and so on. Just in case the proper key is missing on your RL system's keyring, you can use the rpm's --import option to import Rocky Linux’s public key from your local RL system by running: sudo rpm --import /etc/pki/rpm-gpg/RPM-GPG-KEY-rockyofficial

Question

When installing packages, what is the difference between rpm -Uvh and rpm -ivh? Consult the man page for rpm.

Exercise 4

Uninstalling packages

Uninstalling packages is as easy as installing with Red Hat’s package manager (RPM).

In this exercise, you will try to use rpm to uninstall some packages from the system.

To uninstall packages

  1. Uninstall the libmetalink package from your system. Type:

    sudo rpm -e libmetalink
    

    Question

    Explain why you couldn’t remove the package?

  2. The clean and proper way to remove packages using RPM is to remove the package(s) along with their dependencies. To remove libmetalink package we will also have to remove the wget package that depends on it. Type:

    sudo rpm -e libmetalink wget
    

    Note

    If you want to break the package that relies on libmetalink and forcefully remove the package from your system, you can use rpm's --nodeps option like this: $ sudo rpm -e --nodeps libmetalink.

    i. The “nodeps” option means No dependencies. I.e., ignore all dependencies. ii. The above shows you how to remove a package from your system forcefully. Sometimes you need to do this, but it is generally not a good practice. iii. Forcefully removing a package “xyz” that another installed package “abc” relies on effectively makes package “abc” unusable or somewhat broken.

Exercise 5

DNF - package manager

DNF is a package manager for RPM-based Linux distributions. It is the successor to the popular YUM utility. DNF maintains compatibility with YUM. Both utilities share similar command-line options and syntax.

DNF is one of the many tools for managing RPM-based software such as Rocky Linux. Compared to rpm, these higher-level tools help simplify installing, uninstalling, and querying packages. It is important to note that these tools use the underlying framework provided by the RPM system. This is why it is helpful to understand how to use RPM.

DNF (and other tools like it) acts as a sort of wrapper around RPM and provides additional functionality not offered by RPM. DNF knows how to deal with package and library dependencies and also knows how to use configured repositories to resolve most issues automatically.

Common options used with the dnf utility are:

    usage: dnf [options] COMMAND

    List of Main Commands:

    alias                     List or create command aliases
    autoremove                remove all unneeded packages that were originally installed as dependencies
    check                     check for problems in the packagedb
    check-update              check for available package upgrades
    clean                     remove cached data
    deplist                   [deprecated, use repoquery --deplist] List package's dependencies and what packages provide them
    distro-sync               synchronize installed packages to the latest available versions
    downgrade                 Downgrade a package
    group                     display, or use, the groups information
    help                      display a helpful usage message
    history                   display, or use, the transaction history
    info                      display details about a package or group of packages
    install                   install a package or packages on your system
    list                      list a package or groups of packages
    makecache                 generate the metadata cache
    mark                      mark or unmark installed packages as installed by user.
    module                    Interact with Modules.
    provides                  find what package provides the given value
    reinstall                 reinstall a package
    remove                    remove a package or packages from your system
    repolist                  display the configured software repositories
    repoquery                 search for packages matching keyword
    repository-packages       run commands on top of all packages in given repository
    search                    search package details for the given string
    shell                     run an interactive DNF shell
    swap                      run an interactive DNF mod for remove and install one spec
    updateinfo                display advisories about packages
    upgrade                   upgrade a package or packages on your system
    upgrade-minimal           upgrade, but only 'newest' package match which fixes a problem that affects your system

To use dnf for package installation

Assuming you have already uninstalled the wget utility from an exercise, we will use DNF to install the package in the following steps. The 2-3 steps process needed earlier when we installed wget via rpm is now a one step process using dnf. dnf will quietly resolve any dependencies.

  1. First, let us ensure that wget and libmetalink are uninstalled from the system. Type:

    sudo rpm -e wget libmetalink
    

    After removing, if you try running wget from the CLI you see a message like wget: command not found

  2. Now use dnf to install wget. Type:

    sudo dnf -y install wget
    Dependencies resolved.
    ...<TRUNCATED>...
    Installed:
    libmetalink-*           wget-*
    Complete!
    

    Tip

    The "-y" option used in the preceding command suppresses the "[y/N]" prompt to confirm the action that dnf is about to perform. This means that all confirmation actions (or interactive responses) will be "yes" (y).

  3. DNF provides an "Environment Group" option that makes adding a new feature set to a system easy. To add the feature, you would typically have to install a few packages individually, but using dnf, all you need to know is the name or description of the feature you want. Use dnf to display a list of available groups. Type:

    dnf group list
    
  4. We are interested in the "Development Tools" group/feature. Let us get more information about that group. Type:

    bash dnf group info "Development Tools"

  5. Later, we will need some programs with the "Development Tools" group. Install the "Development Tools" group using dnf by running:

    sudo dnf -y group install "Development Tools"
    

To use dnf for uninstalling packages

  1. To use dnf to uninstall the wget package type:

    sudo dnf -y remove wget
    
  2. Use dnf to ensure the package has indeed been removed from the system. Type:

    sudo dnf -y remove wget
    
  3. Try using/running wget. Type:

    wget
    

To use dnf for package update

DNF can check for and install the latest version of individual packages available in repositories. It can also be used to install specific versions of packages.

  1. Use the list option with dnf to view your system's available versions of the wget program. Type:

    dnf list wget
    
  2. If you only want to see if there are updated versions available for a package, use the check-update option with dnf. For example, for the wget package type:

    dnf check-update wget
    
  3. Now, list all the available versions for the kernel package for your system. Type:

    sudo dnf list kernel
    
  4. Next, check if any updated packages are available for the installed kernel package. Type:

    dnf check-update kernel
    
  5. Package updates might be due to bug fixes, new features, or security patches. To view if there are any security related updates for the kernel package, type:

    dnf  --security check-update kernel
    

To use dnf for system updates

DNF can be used to check for and install the latest versions all packages installed on a system. Periodically checking for installing updates is an important aspect of system administration.

  1. To check if there are any updates for the packages you currently have installed on your system, type:

    dnf check-update
    
  2. To check if there are any security related updates for all packages installed on your system, type:

    dnf --security check-update
    
  3. To update the entire packages installed on your system to the most up-to-date versions available for your distribution run:

    dnf -y check-update
    

Exercise 6

Building software from source

All software/applications/packages originate from plain human-readable text files. The files are collectively known as source code. The RPM packages that are installed on Linux distributions are born from source code.

In this exercise, you will download, compile, and install a sample program from its source files. For convenience, source files are usually distributed as a single compressed file called a tar-ball (pronounced tar-dot-gee-zee).

The following exercises will be based on the venerable Hello project source code. hello is a simple command-line application written in C++, that does nothing more than print "hello" to the terminal. You can learn more about the project here

To download the source file

  1. Use curl to download the latest source code for the hello application. Let us download and save the file in the Downloads folder.

    https://ftp.gnu.org/gnu/hello/hello-2.12.tar.gz

To un-tar the file

  1. Change to the directory on your local machine where you downloaded the hello source code.

  2. Unpack (un-tar) the tarball using the tar program. Type:

    tar -xvzf hello-2.12.tar.gz
    

    OUTPUT:

    hello-2.12/
    hello-2.12/NEWS
    hello-2.12/AUTHORS
    hello-2.12/hello.1
    hello-2.12/THANKS
    ...<TRUNCATED>...
    
  3. Use the ls command to view the contents of your pwd.

    A new directory named hello-2.12 should have been created for you during the un-taring.

  4. Change to that directory and list its contents. Type:

    cd hello-2.12 ; ls
    
  5. Reviewing any special installation instructions that might come with the source code is always good practice. Those files usually have names like: INSTALL, README and so on.

    Use a pager to open up the INSTALL file and read it. Type:

    less INSTALL
    

    Exit the pager when you are done reviewing the file.

To configure the package

Most applications have features that can be enabled or disabled by the user. This is one of the benefits of having access to the source code and installing from the same. You have control over the application's configurable features. This is in contrast to accepting everything a package manager installs from pre-compiled binaries.

The script that usually lets you configure the software is usually aptly named “configure”

Tip

Make sure that you have the "Development Tools" package group installed before attempting to complete the following exercises.

sudo dnf -y group install "Development Tools"
  1. Use the ls command again to ensure that you indeed have a file named configure in your pwd.

  2. To see all the options, you can enable or disable in the hello program type:

    ./configure --help
    

    Question

    From the output of the command what does the “--prefix” option do?

  3. If you are happy with the default options that the configure script offers. Type:

    ./configure
    

    Note

    Hopefully the configure stage went smoothly and you can go on to the compilation stage.

    If you get some errors during the configure stage, you should carefully look through the output's tail-end to see the error's source. The errors are sometimes self-explanatory and easy to fix. For example, you might see an error like:

    configure: error: no acceptable C compiler found in $PATH

    The above error simply means that you don’t have a C Compiler (e.g., gcc) installed on the system or the compiler is installed somewhere that is not in your PATH variable.

To compile the package

You will build the hello application in the following steps. This is where some of the programs that come with the Development Tools group that you installed earlier using DNF come in handy.

  1. Use the make command to compile the package after running the “configure” script. Type:

    make
    

    OUTPUT:

    gcc  -g -O2   -o hello src/hello.o  ./lib/libhello.a
    make[2]: Leaving directory '/home/rocky/hello-2.12'
    ...<OUTPUT TRUNCATED>...
    make[1]: Leaving directory '/home/rocky/hello-2.12'
    

    If all goes well - this important make step is the step that will help generate the final hello application binary.

  2. List the files in your current working directory again. You should see some newly created files in there including the hello program.

To install the application

Amongst other housekeeping tasks, the final installation step also involves copying any application binaries and libraries over to the proper folders.

  1. To install the hello application run the make install command. Type:

    sudo make install
    

    This will install package into the location specified by the default prefix (--prefix) argument that may have been used with the “configure” script earlier. If no --prefix was set, a default prefix of /usr/local/ will be used.

To run the hello program

  1. Use the whereis command to see where the hello program is on your system. Type:

    whereis hello
    
  2. Try running the hello application to see what it does. Type:

    hello
    
  3. Run hello again, with the --help option to see the other things it can do.

  4. Now using sudo, run hello again as a superuser. Type:

    sudo hello
    

    OUTPUT:

    sudo: hello: command not found
    

    Question

    Investigate what causes the error when you try running hello with sudo. Fix the issue and make sure the hello program can be used with sudo.

    Tip

    It is good practice to test a program as a regular user to ensure that regular users can indeed use the program. It is possible that the permissions on the binary are set incorrectly such that only the super-user can use the programs. This of course assumes that you indeed want regular users to be able to use the program.

  5. That's it. This exercise is complete!

Exercise 7

Checking file integrity after package installation

After installing relevant packages, in some cases, we need to determine whether the associated files have been modified to prevent malicious modifications by others.

File verification

Using the "-V" option of the rpm command.

Take the time synchronization program chrony as an example to illustrate the meaning of its output.

  1. To demonstrate how the rpm package verification works, make a modification to chrony's configuration file - /etc/chrony.conf. (It is assumed that you have installed chrony). Add 2 harmless comment ## symbols to the end of the file. Type:

    echo -e "##"  | sudo tee -a /etc/chrony.conf
    
  2. Now run the rpm command with the --verify option. Type:

    rpm -V chrony
    

    OUTPUT:

    S.5....T.  c  /etc/chrony.conf
    

    The output is broken down into 3 separate columns.

    • First Column (S.5....T.)

      The sample output - S.5....T. indicates the 9 fields that are used to indicate useful information about the validity of files in an RPM package. Any field or characteristic that passed a given check/test is indicated by a ".".

      These 9 different fields or checks are described here:

      • S: Whether the size of the file has been modified.
      • M: Whether the type of file or file permissions (rwx) have been modified.
      • 5: Whether the file MD5 checksum has modified.
      • D: Whether the number of the device has been modified.
      • L: Whether the path to the file has been modified.
      • U: Whether the owner of the file has been modified.
      • G: Whether the group to which the file belongs has been modified.
      • T: Whether the mTime (modify time) of the file has been modified.
      • P: Whether the program function has been modified.
    • Second Column (c)

      • c: Indicates modifications to the configuration file. It can also be the following values:
      • d: documentation file.
      • g: ghost file. Very few can be seen.
      • l: license file.
      • r: readme file.
    • Third column (/etc/chrony.conf)

      • /etc/chrony.conf: Represents the path of the modified file.

Author: Wale Soyinka

Contributors: Steven Spencer, tianci li, Ganna Zhyrnova